Walking into Wildwood, the latest film from the amazing Laika studios, I was anticipating a beautiful, long, and darker tale from the studio, but when I left I felt as if I had escaped a grim, confused and underbaked fantasy film that left me revolted at times with how vial and underwritten this story is.
***Spoilers for Wildwood***
To the filmmaker’s (Travis Knight) credit, the film opening tips you off from the get go that we are about to experience something darker and upsetting, as we watch a boy strip bare (multiple butt shots!), rip out his revealed to be mechanical heart and they throw themself to their death off a balcony; right in front of their mother (who we later learn is the Dowager Governess Alexandra). To complicate matters further, at the discovery of the boy’s automaton nature, Alexandra’s people turn against her. Got to admit, a pretty great start here!
Sadly, the alarm bells started warming up fairly soon after, as our film’s hero (Prue) is painted in an odd bit of characterization. She’s a great big sister, we know that, and that’s important to the launching pad of this film, but her connection with her parents (a couple of wet blankets played admirably enough by Jake Johnson & Maya Erskine) is one of not necessarily a rebellious teenager (is she a teen?), but of a kid trying to grow up too fast. Prue thinks they are smarter than their parents (and she may be, the parents are presented as being real dumb) and is presented as someone who is completely self-centered (beyond her love for her brother). Now, these seem like some solid starting points for a character to learn some lessons across a grand fairy tale, but she isn’t that appealing from the outset and her final takeaway from her journey when this thing is all said and done is a baffling life lesson to end the movie on.
From here, we get the highlight of the film, a beautiful travelogue of a stop-motion Portland. Gorgeous and exacting in hitting the highlights of the city, wonderfully and lovingly crafted and re-created by Laika, but that high note fades quickly as we are introduced to our co-lead of the film; Curtis. Now, Curtis’ introduction is unfortunate on a couple of fronts. First, he is the fucking worst. I mean, he’s unbearable to listen to and you are just dreading the fact that he is going to get dragged along on this adventure. So, we could forgive Prue for being mostly agnostic towards our spectacled anti-friend attempting to tag along on her and her baby bro’s (completely rule breaking and unsanctioned) joyride to the school playground, but her disrespect for him feels overly harsh even for how much he sucks. It all starts with Prue shaming Curtis for drinking hot coco, instead of coffee like cool adult-kids like her (though, point to Prue for buying him a new drink after spilling his first), and the disrespect keeps coming as she makes fun of him for basically everything that comes out of his mouth; which, even if fair, is really rude and disrespectful.
Prue is eventually distracted while she really tears into Curtis’ awfulness, and that’s when a murder of crows swoops in and steals her baby brother Mac. It looks beautiful, scary and raises the stakes in a moment that should be full of terror and dread; visually, the Laika team nails it. But, when Prue hops on her bike and accidentally scoops up Curtis in her trailer, the accompanying chase to catch up to her brother is not cut to a dark and dreadful crescendo of score and terror, the film treats the sequence as an x-treme action set-piece with an accompanying needle drop that completely misinterprets the moment and what is happening on screen.
The alarm bells are blaring…
From here, Prue and Curtis find their way inside the Impassable Wilderness thanks to a bit of blood magic, previously alluded to a few scenes earlier when Prue cut her hand and it affected a sad house plant (but, weirdly, the film keeps her oblivious to the fact that she allowed them access because of her blood in a strange bit of withholding). They quickly run into a pack of talking coyotes wearing colonial military uniforms and wielding weapons, who we discover serve the Dowager Governess. Now, I’m liking the look and feel of these coyotes at first, it feels straight out of an 80’s fantasy “kids” picture, but they don’t come across as all that scary and are a bit too dopey for my taste. For the coyotes there isn’t much more motivation behind their allegiance and villain turn to be had in the movie; so color me horrified as they are exposed to basically be fascist minions who will kill at will as the film goes on. There was room for allegory there, but the film feels disinterested, or unwilling, to paint their penchant for oppression beyond anything other than the plot’s need for a bad guy army.
Our lead heroes are quickly spotted by this band of bad guys, and are off running through the woods trying to escape their evil clutches. What happens next is the first of many confounding turn of events when, Curtis, who we’ve known for a whole five minutes and has been treated like absolute dogshit by Prue, decides he must sacrifice himself for Prue’s quest for her brother and gets most of the gang to chase him away on another path. The film’s penchant for violence starts rearing its ugly head here, as a lone coyote who was left to chase Prue gets quite brutally run over by a bumbling mail man; whose purpose in this story is nothing more than expository chess piece mover. We meet a bunch of birds, the Avian Principality, and their leader “The General”, establishing some further realms and factions of Wildwood, but Prue moves on without incident to a bureaucratic nightmare building that seemingly is going to set up our film’s antagonists.
The setting is the same mansion we see in the film’s opening, and the sets, characters and sequence are lively and wonderfully dotted with interesting bits and animations, but the two characters of this corner of Wildwood are so buffonish and unfunny, my head was spinning as I was pulled between the pointlessness of this plot and the beauty on screen. The plainly evil bureaucrats (the leader being a character we see in the cold open, who uses the Governess’ pain and loss to usurp her power) lock Prue away in a room, that she quickly escapes from before moving on to the next information dump needed to explain this world to us. The escape is fun and has a couple of dumb jokes at a dog’s expense, but the ease at which Prue was able to escape immediately undercuts the stakes around the danger she may be in.
Concurrently, Curtis is captured and taken to meet our film’s true antagonist Alexandra, who has gone full native and (on multiple occasions) has waking delusions of Curtis as her son. She’s presented as a truly broken and delirious woman, who is completely untethered from reality and on a warpath for revenge against the Bandits(?). We see Alexandra surveying her victorious battlefield, littered with dead soldiers on both sides of the battle, and for some reason she decides to hold the captured bandit king and a small pack of his followers alive for… nobody knows; oh plot. From here, Curtis is given a few more glimmers of decency because he befriends a talking rat, who re-enforces that Alexandra is the absolutely fucking worst to him and the viewer. This is the first of many times where the film will try to put us against Alexandra and there is no empathy to be found for this character who is clearly suffering through some level of grief that we can’t remotely understand at this point.
Checking in on how this all feels to the viewer, the film is holding my attention because of the beauty and the what the fuck nature of what is being put on screen, but it’s also not that entertaining, is ploddingly paced and seems to be just stopping in every scene to tell us what’s going on in the most expository way possible; by having a character just monologue information at you. Which brings us to the most baffling scene (more to come!) of the movie so far.
Owl Rex (what a terrible name), the apparent Crown Prince of Wildwood, who has taken Prue in after her escape from the mansion, tells her a story of tragedy and sympathy for Alexandra; except the film hopes it will villainize her. The story does not build fear for her, Alexandra is grieving the death of her son (and husband), and while what she is doing is a tad extreme, it’s not all that irrational that she would think putting the last bit of her son’s soul into a look-alike automaton will make her feel better. And it works, she’s happy again, but the film never investigates what really made it all go wrong for her and her “re-born” son.
Rex has taken the side of the bad faith bureaucrats trying to overthrow Wildwood, who are also on the hunt for Rex as well! Plus, there is no contemplating the grey area that Rex is using this villainizing story of Alexandra to try to claim the throne for himself; an interesting opportunity squandered at this junction of the story where we and Prue don’t know who to trust. For the film, this sequence is meant to be another feather in the cap of how bad and threatening Alexandra is, not a portrait of someone railroaded by the system and cast out of society. While seeming to be quite oblivious to the empathy of her story and the complexity this character has; and this is before the later revelations of why she is kidnapping Prue’s brother in the first place. It would be one thing if the film was trying to be morally ambiguous, but the film seems to just be going through the motions of having a bad guy for the stake of its story and is throwing Alexandra under the bus to get it. The film also doesn’t even remotely try to wrestle with Alexandra’s decision to resurrect her son, why he decides he must kill himself, or how the coyotes become loyal to her. So much is left off the table, and everything that is put on the table doesn’t make me think she’s evil!
I’m really struggling with the film’s messaging and pacing at this point and the film doesn’t want you to think about all the questions it is raising. Just as you might pause to ask yourself, “Hey, wait a sec…,” the plot quickly pivots to the reveal that Alexandra is going to kill Prue’s baby brother, the majestic eagle The General is murdered as Prue attempts to escape (again, as Rex’s is ransacked) to the Mystics (spoiler it’s magical people of color 😬), Curtis is imprisoned with some bandits (many of which get shot and killed in cages) and Alexandra reveals to the now captured Prue that her brother has been killed and that Prue should just leave Wildwood; remember, this is a “dark” movie.
And so Prue leaves, even though we are shown she does not remotely believe Alexandra (because she’s not some dumb kid, you know), and I’m left wondering what the fuck is going on! What! Then the movie somehow gets even more wild (no pun intended) with another baffling reveal.
So, way back in the first scenes of the film, Prue’s parents leave her in charge to babysit her brother, and they implore her that Mac must never leave the inside of the house (WTF); but we still don’t know why those crows seemed ready and willing to scoop him up. Upon Prue’s return to her Portland home, after being gone for hours (days?) and without her brother Mac, her parents reveal that Prue herself was conceived through dark magic at the hands of Alexandra; after they had exhausted all their options around their infertility. A crazy lady under a bridge implored Prue’s parents to go to a certain spot to solve their infertility problems, and Alexandra appears to them out of the mist and makes a very clear deal. She’ll give them the gift of a child with her magic, but if they ever have another child, they will have to give it up to Alexandra; forever. So Alexandra didn’t kidnap Mac, she was just following through on the promise Prue’s parents made with her and have reneged on. She doesn’t trick them, there is no fine print, Prue’s parents knew the deal and they could have very easily avoided having a second kid who, from their own admission, they didn’t even need, want, nor tried to have. Because these two dimwitted Portland hippies couldn’t follow through on a birth control plan, they had this baby that they agreed to give away. I hate to say it, but Alexandra did nothing wrong!
Well, Alexandra shouldn’t kill the baby, obviously, but the film (again) doesn’t try to wrestle with this revelation and the implication it has on everything that came before it; nor what is going to happen going forward. Alexandra has been turned to the dark path, but so many factors led her there, factors driven by love, betrayal (it’s revealed her husband emotionally abandons her after their son’s death, drinking himself to death) and manipulation, but the film doesn’t care about that, she’s just a bad guy. Prue does decide her parents are a real pair of pieces of shit (a fair assessment), and basically throws herself back into Wildwood to try and save her brother because no one else seems to care all that much.
This detour out of the Wildwood, even with the crazy revelations it has in store, feels like a lead balloon on the pacing of the film. Everything stops moving forward for another monologue of information dump, only to just move Prue back to where they were a scene or two before. It would be one thing if, again, the film had any real interest in wrestling with what all this means for Prue and her relationship to her parents. Will she leave her Portland family with Mac after this betrayal? Are these even her biological parents? Is Alexandra her mother? Is Mac her brother by blood? Is family not in the blood, but in the bonds? The film doesn’t even hint at any interest in any of this by the end; making this diversion out of Wildwood even more confusing once the credits roll.
As Prue heads back to Wildwood, Curtis helps with the escape of the Bandits (somehow Curtis is now a full blown member, even after his cage shenanigans got a number of their Bandit friends executed?) and is conveniently able to inform them of Alexandra’s plan to sacrifice Mac at the Ancient Grove. The threat level on the film is risen when Prue returns and connects with the mystics (whose story function is playing the part of “Magical Negro”, except as an elderly Indigenous American woman and her people of color friends), asking them for help with saving Mac. The mystics gather and attempt to use their mystical abilities to commune with their special tree, yet they see no threat, only for Prue to reveal Alexandra’s true plan when she touches the tree. Prue’s magical abilities are never really discussed or grappled with, as these supposedly mystical people move on from this shocking turn of events without nary a thought.
Prue reveals Alexandra plans to gain control of the Ivy, resurrect her son and, seemingly, destroying Wildwood in the process. This is bad, but you could argue that everyone falsely believes that she will destroy Wildwood? This is one person’s vision, who has no experience in being a seer or using magic, and is a complete outsider to everyone in Wildwood. Hell, she shouldn’t be trusted as being the potential offspring of Alexandra, but the film is by no means interested in any of this tension or drama. Anyways, because some folks have potentially false delusions around Alexandra’s intent and some random kid showed them the future, the now present Bandits and Mystics decide that everyone in the Wildwood must be conscripted into an army to do battle with Alexandra; sacrificing countless lives in the process.
This all reeks of sloppy plotting and wannabe fantasy storytelling, and while the film captures the fear and hesitance surrounding these helpless and not battle ready citizens heading off to battle, you can’t help to ask yourself why it had to go this way. Nobody knows anything about Alexandra beyond she’s “bad”, the fear is arguably propaganda, and even though Alexandra has waged battle against the bandits we don’t really know how all this turned this sour in the first place. On top of all these failures of world building, why, in the year 2026, would we want to build a story and message around the idea that the only way to solve problems is by slaughtering each other. I understand this film is years in development and that re-shooting or pivoting the plot of stop-motion film could be hard, timely and expensive, but at a script stage this all feels quite misguided of a message to be telling. And that’s setting aside this is a film that will be seen by countless children as their gateway into fantasy storytelling on this scale.
Still, there was time for the story to reverse course from here. Let Alexandra and Prue talk. Let them work it out before all these lives are sacrificed. But, no, that’s not the path this story takes. Instead, we are given a grand battle, between Alexandra’s army and the bandits, that is full of bloodlust and carnage without ever stopping to wonder about the cost of what we are seeing has on anyone involved. In fact, when it’s all said and done, the good guys basically just cheer and move on. No mourning the dead, no grief from their losses, just faceless violence for the viewer to marvel at and not wonder the why of it all.
The artistry on hand for this battle is nothing short of astonishing, it’s so visceral and well executed that I was left revolted at the violence. Laika’s execution is impeccable from a production stand point, which only grows the contrast of how the story side of things wasn’t given the same care and attention to detail. And hey, maybe people were affected in the same way I was, viewing this battle as the horrors and senseless nature of war, but it never felt like that was the film’s intent. It felt like cool kills and awe chasing, which they achieved, but it felt wrong to embrace a story like this in times like these.
After the battle is mostly wrapped up, the film delivers its coup de grâce to any chance of telling a moral tale, with the coup de grâce of a pair of bad guys at the hands of our heroes. Curtis and Prue both commit murder at the end of their arcs in this story and with that the film reached that level of feeling amoral as both deaths are done in a way that provides almost no introspection or wonder in why they did it.
Curtis, whom it’s telegraphed very early on that he’s going to kill someone by the end of this film, makes his murder on the “big bad” of the coyotes clan; just as the coyote’s about to, very terrifyingly, kill Prue. Curtis’ actions could be excused as the costs of war, but why are we weighing those in the first place? And while Curtis does stare at his hands after killing the coyote, I wonder if any viewers actually view it as him walking through a rite of passage to becoming an adult? The film certainly foreshadows earlier in the film that this is what this moment is supposed to be. You kill to be defined as a man, and again, I’m left wondering how we let this sort of toxic mindset escape the script stage.
Where Curtis’ murder is attempted to be given cover by the potential fog of war, Prue’s is rationalized in the rescue of her brother. After one last bit of back and forth between Alexandra and the lead mystic, a dialogue which is here only to firmly establish Alexandra has to be killed, Alexandra and Prue are pitted against each other high above the battlefield in the Ancient Grove (the naming structure for this fantasy world is also boring as hell). Alexandra, inches away from plunging a knife into Mac, is thwarted by a bit of blood magic by Prue who successfully whirls her brother out of harm’s way by controlling the ivy; even though she has never used magic once in her life. The film tosses off a bit of dialogue earlier setting this up, “you got to talk to it,” but it all stinks of lazy writing and deus ex machina shenanigans. It all feels so rushed out of necessity, when the clearly more compelling conclusion to this story would have been investigating the connection between these two characters; which may even be that they are kin. Instead, the film is more excited to have Prue murder Alexandra, a woman full of complications and contradictions, rather than understand her, with a “cool kill” by vines; Prue using the same “dark magic” that made Alexandra the bad guy in this story. Do I think the film is aware of that contradiction, no I do not and that’s a shame. Is this the time to also lament that this film, mostly about women and the world around them, was written and directed by two men?
The good guys win, everyone celebrates (at least they let the remaining coyotes escape and survive, wouldn’t have put it past this film to execute the remaining soldiers), Prue apologizes to Curtis for treating him like shit and the Portland natives leave Wildwood behind them. But we do get one last scene before the credits roll, one where Prue is racked with feelings of unease at what adulthood can turn you into; a dark and unsettling final moment for a film that never seemed to care, or try to be about, this doubt.
That final moment caught me off guard, in that it seemed to be wrestling with all of the feelings I’ve laid out in so many words above, but the film never seemed interested in these feelings until this point. There were, clearly, so many opportunities to expand and/or alter this story’s path, but it seemed to be driven instead by telling what it thought it was a tried and true fantasy action epic (for boys?). Maybe the nuance and morality I was hoping to find was lost in translation (I haven’t, and probably won’t, seek out the series it’s adapting after my experience here), and while I appreciated some doubt and complexity finally being tossed into the mix, it ultimately sends you out of the film with a sense of whiplash; and by no means a feeling of finality. I don’t know if they hoped to make more of these, especially given there are more stories to tell, but it all just feels short sighted to not tell a complete story here first. A lot of my complaints and wonders may have gotten re-examined in future installments, but I’m not sure I’m ever going to get the chance to see.
Laika’s craft and skills, ultimately, feel wasted on Wildwood, even if this work is still worth seeing on the biggest screen possible. Wildwood seems to have been the studio taking a shot at making something geared towards an older audience than they’ve catered to in the past (though, their previous works feel like films many families share across generations), but those aspirations have seemingly left them with a piece of art that is visually more mature with no heart at its core. It’s a shame.
Better luck next time, Laika.